I Am and Diversity Dialogues seek to reach their audiences on an intimate level, appealing to their shared humanity. Each being is a unique self, defined by his relationship to and treatment of others. By conversing with the other selves of the world, we can better understand our “self.” Once we understand who we are, we can work on becoming who we’d like to become.
Director Tom Shadyac, best known for his comedies like Ace Ventura, created the documentary I Am following a life-changing experience. After an unfortunate incident involving his bicycle, Shadyac experienced stressful symptoms such as hypersensitivity to stimuli that produced painful headaches. Worse still, the symptoms continued well beyond the expected recovery period. Submerged in a sea of anguish, he decided to reevaluate his way of life. He discovered that his vast material wealth and worldly success did not fill the hole in his soul. He was not happy. By interviewing some of the greatest thinkers of our time, he set out to find the key to happiness.
Ironically, he found that his competitive drive—encouraged by the capitalist society in which he was raised—had separated him from his fellow beings, perpetuating feelings of loneliness and anxiety. The more things we own, the more we are owned. In nature, animals are compassionate toward their kind. Shadyac ultimately concluded that compassion is the key to harmony. We are all connected and part of the same global family. It is only when we learn to value compassion over competition and caring over consumption that we can find true joy.
***
Creative Nonfiction, Diversity Dialogues offers a breadth of essays spanning topics from race to health while providing a plethora of narrative techniques from which to draw inspiration. Each author writes from a specific vantage point, but all appeal to logic and emotion. Authors convey their personal investment in the topics explored, showing how their “selves” are impacted by the issues in question.
Both “The Brown Study” by Richard Rodriguez and “Snapshots in Black and White” by Shara McCallum are enjoyable, thought provoking essays which deal with the complex relationship between race and social identity, examining how the two result in self-conceptualization.
In his essay “The Brown Study,” Rodriguez examines the impact of color on one’s perspective and status. He is frustrated that the labels of homosexuality and minority confine his work to a specific audience; he longs to reach a diverse populace, but still he cannot deny that his racial identity informs his interaction with and outlook of the world. He follows “the A, B, Cs” well, hooking the audience with “Or, as a brown man, I think.” Using historical and scientific data, Rodriquez explores the realm of color and the associations society makes with regard to specific colors, pointing out rampant misconceptions. Vanilla, for example, traditionally is viewed as bland and white, while in actuality it is brown when extracted in its purest form. He commands attention and asserts his authority while injecting his own personal concerns as a human being who loves to write.
In “Snapshots in Black and White,” McCallum links racial identification with family unity. She appears and “passes” for Caucasian although heavily mixed. In a world plagued by labels, she is stuck in a dangerous limbo of racial ambiguity. Unsure of the color with which to identify, she is not fully embraced by either the black or white crowd. To further strengthen her piece, sexuality is examined in addition to race. Just as McCallum can pass for white, her aunt can “pass” as straight. Although she is a lesbian, the aunt is reticent to proclaim her sexuality due to her fear that she will be socially reprimanded. She understands that labeling yourself in social terms is suffocating and involves repercussions. But without claiming a team, one is alone and, in a sense, homeless. McCallum informs us that race amounts to more than genes and skin tone; it is how you view yourself and with whom you choose to identify—who you call your family. In a polarized society with no tolerance for gray, identification impacts one’s status and dictates the treatment he receives from others. People are multifaceted and appearances can be deceiving.
In her essay “Gone in Translation,” Kate Small concentrates on a small group of social misfits in an isolated environment. Within one setting, Small is able to explore a variety of personalities with fluid dialogue and pacing which propels the story forward. She makes her characters human and relatable despite (or because) of their socially-labeled flaws and failures.
Kate Small immediately reels readers into “Gone in Translation” with her bleak description of the image of a family plagued by the Dust Bowl:
“The house strains against too many occupants and a hot, hard wind…A white girl whose knees are black with grime—I have her neck” (92).
The author identifies with the impoverished farming family, realizing that she could be in their unfortunate position. The image establishes the theme for the piece, setting a somber tone. Amidst poverty, economic decay, and social instability, people rely on family and friends to transcend their struggles. Small explores the relationship between poverty and family by examining images, and revealing the tightly woven familial friendship among her fellow restaurant patrons.
Floyd Skloot’s “A Measure of Acceptance” is an impactful essay written by a virally brain-damaged man over a period of eleven months, detailing the humiliating tests he endured to keep his disability payments and prove his ailment is authentic. As in “Gone in Translation,” the mainstream of successful and/or healthy people stigmatize and discriminate against those less fortunate then themselves, thinking them freeloaders and freaks.
Terry Williams opens with an emotionally wrenching description of gassed prairie dogs in “Prayer Dogs.” Depicting panic and pain immediately earns reader sympathy for the afflicted creatures. She inserts plenty of dialogue, interacts with others—both pro and anti-animal rights, prairie dogs themselves, while using a plethora of data to support her case.
By evoking emotional responses which give readers hope that through struggle positive change is possible, the authors of I Am and Diversity Dialogues provide the intimacy needed to inspire self-reflection. In this way, they encourage us to take responsibility for the selves we have created. But, more importantly, they encourage us to compose better, more accepting and compassionate selves.